论坛首页    职业区    学术与写作    工程技术区    软件区    资料区    商务合作区    社区办公室
 您好! 欢迎 登录 或 注册 最新帖子 邀请注册 活动聚焦 统计排行 社区服务 帮助
 
  • 帖子
  • 日志
  • 用户
  • 版块
  • 群组
帖子
  • 14904阅读
  • 9回复

Geotechnical Engineering, Proceedings of ICE  是不是SCI检索 [复制链接]

上一主题 下一主题
离线xhydingpei
 

发帖
98
土币
546
威望
144
原创币
0
只看楼主 倒序阅读 使用道具 楼主  发表于: 2011-01-04
请教高手:
如题:1、Geotechnical Engineering, Proceedings of ICE 是不是SCI检索
2、杂志给的审稿信件
Thank you for your submitting your article to Geotechnical Engineering. Following peer review, your article was judged acceptable for publication subject to appropriate revision.
审稿人给了11条意见,有没有发过这个杂志的兄弟姐妹,看看希望大不?谢谢了!!
PEER REVIEW COMMENTS
Assessors combined comments:

The paper presents interesting work and results and should make a useful paper. The following comments and suggestions are made for the author to improve the clarity of the paper prior to resubmission of the paper.

1. The keywords do not represent the main concept of the paper. Some parameters such as coeffificent of consolidation should be included.

2. In the introduction, the author should clarify why they did this research, i.e. what was unclear and how important it is, which made them do their research to clarify it.

3. Saturation of the samples affects the coeffificent of consolidation. Was ther degree of saturation measured? If so how? This should be explained in the paper.

4. Include the physical properties of the clay investigated.

5. A theoretical solution for derivation of Equation 8 are used but the coefficient of permeability are used from an empirical equation?

6. Figure captions should summarize the figure topic/content, rather than a comment on the trends shown in the figures.

7. In Figs 4 and 7 and others, plots are function of effective stress, but it is not shown on these figures what is the effective stress.

8. The experimental work is on one clay - can the results apply to all types of soils??

9. In the theoritical part of the paper, please make sure that derivation of every formula is correct, clear, and easy to follow.

10. Please compare your findings with Terzaghi's theory and the other published opinions. The findings should appear in the Abstract, Discussion of the results, and in the conclusions. The findings in these sections should be similar.

11. The grammer of the paper should be critically reviewed and improved. Please make sure that the manuscript is free of typo errors & incomplete/incorrect sentences. Also please use the proper tenses, e.g. do not use the future tense when you talk about comparisons that you already made, or your findings. For example a number of specific comments on the text are listed below:




离线shawn

发帖
572
土币
2725
威望
953
原创币
0
只看该作者 1楼 发表于: 2011-01-05
Good International Journal. Congratulations! Accepted with minor revisions! Very promising to be publish.
离线lmm

发帖
2465
土币
2026
威望
7364
原创币
0
只看该作者 2楼 发表于: 2011-01-05
是sci
和Geotechnique同属于ICE主办的
------------------
离线patton4400

发帖
184
土币
394
威望
476
原创币
0
只看该作者 3楼 发表于: 2011-01-05
恭喜了~~~~~
离线gaoflying

发帖
1881
土币
12058
威望
191
原创币
0
只看该作者 4楼 发表于: 2011-01-14
羡慕啊,兄弟
专注于工作,散漫于生活
离线zzb2007

发帖
115
土币
294956
威望
15
原创币
0
只看该作者 5楼 发表于: 2011-09-08
国内有那些岩土类的期刊是被sci检索的呢?
离线ggbbggb

发帖
46
土币
110
威望
29
原创币
0
只看该作者 6楼 发表于: 2011-09-09
这些comments不算大改,总共11条,有几条极简单。杂志比geotechnique低一点,但是还是不错的sci。

最新出的geotechnique letter好像暂时什么都不是。

国内没有专门的岩土杂志是sci,国内几个SCI如固体力学学报(英文版)等都收录岩土方向的文章。
GGbbGGb
离线disciple

发帖
206
土币
4712
威望
766
原创币
0
只看该作者 7楼 发表于: 2011-12-25
学习了。@!@!@
离线yangkel

发帖
57
土币
377
威望
3
原创币
0
只看该作者 8楼 发表于: 2011-12-30
严重恭喜并强烈佩服中...
离线shuiyu99

发帖
323
土币
11221
威望
456
原创币
0
只看该作者 9楼 发表于: 2011-12-30
提出的修改意见非常有价值,不仅给出了建议,也给出一种外文或中文学术论文描述问题的思路。
一壶浊酒喜相逢!
快速回复
限100 字节
温馨提示:欢迎交流讨论,请勿纯表情、纯引用!
 
上一个 下一个

      https://beian.mps.gov.cn/ 粤公网安备 44010602012919号 广州半山岩土网络科技有限公司 粤ICP备2024274469号

      工业和信息化部备案管理系统网站